Santa Clara County Assessor Larry Stone is asking the Superior Court to review the Assessment Appeals Board’s ruling that reduced by half ($6 million) the San Francisco 49ers’ property tax — possessory interest — for its use of Santa Clara’s Levi’s Stadium.
“The board’s decision ignores many of the 49ers’ valuable rights and instead simply splits the value of the stadium exactly in half between the 49ers and the public authority,” Stone said in a press release Monday morning, “a position for which neither side argued, that no data supported, and that no lawful valuation method can justify.”
In a court filing made public Monday, the Assessor asks the court to return the question to the Appeals Board with instructions to recalculate the NFL team’s interest using “a method reasonably calculated to capture the full value.” The Appeals Board based its decision on the stadium contracts, not on any calculation of financial benefits.
Stone’s petition alleges that, in its review, the Appeals Board used an “unauthorized valuation method” — a provision of the tax rules that applies to time-limited or shared possession — to arrive at its conclusion that the 49ers and the Santa Clara Stadium Authority each held a 50 percent interest in Levi’s Stadium.
This conclusion, wrote Santa Clara County Counsel James Williams, was based on a misunderstanding of the “seasons” specified in the contract.
“The Board mistakenly concluded that each party was given scheduling priority for six months of the year and thus had the right to occupy the Stadium for an equal number of days.” Further, “The Board compounded its error by concluding that any differences in the parties’ respective Stadium uses could be disregarded.”
“A 49ers witness emphasized during the hearing,” Williams noted, “that the parties’ contracts were primarily focused on allocating rights based on types of stadium use, rather than by time.”
The Appeals Board should have determined the team’s possessory interest, the County says, by calculating the value of the Stadium Authority’s interest and subtracting that from the overall value of the stadium.
The County’s position is that the contracts approved by the Santa Clara City Council in 2011, 2012 and 2013 give the 49ers significant more business benefit from Levi’s Stadium than that received by Stadium Authority. This is the proper basis for determining the tax amount, not the assignment of 49ers and Stadium Authority seasons.
The profits generated for the public entities were insignificant compared to those “generated by the 49ers’ very different and far superior uses,” Williams wrote.
The petition points to scheduling priority for NFL football games — for which the 49ers receive all the profit — as well as 49ers’ rights to Stadium sponsorship deals; control over Stadium branding and partnerships; year-round exclusive use of the team store, suites, locker rooms, training spaces and museum; right to lease commercial areas of the stadium year-round; and year-round use of the stadium spaces for marketing, promotional events and tours.
“Laced throughout the parties’ agreements are a variety of provisions rendering the Authority’s rights subordinate to those of the 49ers,” says the petition, including “multiple avenues to veto … events,” a right the Stadium Authority doesn’t have.
The Stadium Authority retained “the far less profitable” non-NFL events “which suffer from largely one-off marketing and set-up costs as well as exorbitant promoter fees …and …are…disproportionately impacted by a City Council imposed curfew.”
The County called the City’s direct revenue from Levi’s Stadium insignificant. This revenue includes ticket fees, ground rent, and 50 percent of the net profit of all non-NFL events — “performance rent,” listed as a Stadium Authority expense.
The Stadium Authority’s revenue streams — stadium naming rights, seat licenses and the 49ers’ roughly $25 million in annual facilities rent— are applied to construction debt, operating expenses and reserves in the “waterfall” financing structure approved by the City Council in 2011.
The County, however, appears confused about the financial structure of the stadium, seeming to infer that City benefit depends on money flowing through the various debt obligations and reserve accounts ultimately into the general fund.
Public discussions of the financing in 2010 and 2011 were focused on making sure that the City had no liability for stadium debt or expenses, and that there was an assured revenue stream for these costs, not direct general fund income.
The benefits argued for an NFL stadium in 2010 were overall economic impact to the City, as well as incremental tax revenue for Santa Clara Unified School District and county agencies that serve the City.
“In 2010,” the City said in a press statement, “the 49ers appeared to fully support and understand the millions of dollars in tax revenue that would go to the community from their stadium interest as demonstrated through campaign materials in support of Measure J that would bring a stadium to Santa Clara.”
Read the County Assessor’s petition here: County assessor Petition 5-20-19
View Comments (1)
To Lower Costs, Trump to Force Hospitals to Reveal Price of Care. A proposed federal rule would make hospitals list the prices they negotiate with insurers, allowing consumers to seek better deals for care. Kanye West performs for Houston jail inmates. Kanye West and his choir stopped at the Harris County Jail in Houston, Texas for a surprise concert. Yahaira Jacquez reports. Bristol face Justin Tipuric battle after making 500,000-a-year offer as French clubs circle. NIK SIMON - THE GAINLINE Justin Tipuric is weighing up a 500,000-a-year offer from Bristol - but some of France's biggest clubs are also keen on the Wales flanker. Meeting the Brother Who Cant Remember Her. In Thanhha Lais Butterfly Yellow, a Vietnamese refugee finds the brother taken from her family as a toddler. Much more than just time separates them. 'Welcome and Respect' banners greet England team in Kosovo ahead of Euro 2020 qualifier. Such is the sense of gratitude felt for the British government's role in the 1999 NATO bombing raids which brought independence to Kosovo, banners and poppies cover the capital. Driver is caught with '$200,000 cash and ice in his car' after a chase with police. Police say the 42-year-old man was found in a backyard in Mount Pritchard in Sydney by a police dog on Friday. E-cigarette use increased by 14% last year as cigarette smoking fell to an all-time low. E-cigarette use among adults in the US increased from 2.8% in 2017 to 3.2% in 2018 as smoking fell to 13.7% in 2018 from 14% in 2017, the second year in a row for a record-low, the CDC revealed. Norway's Arctic idyll shivers at oil plans. Oil companies seeking new Arctic areas for exploration face a battle with environmentalists, fishermen and hotel owners over Norwegian islands where jagged snow-capped peaks rise sheer from the sea. Ellen DeGeneres to get Golden Globe lifetime award for TV work. Comedian Ellen DeGeneres will get a lifetime achievement award at the Golden Globes next year recognizing her 25-year career on U.S. television, organizers said on Monday. Dia Art Foundation Welcomes Whitney Veteran Donna De Salvo. Ms. De Salvo will advise on the collection, exhibitions and long-term installations while also developing Dias archive. Measles Makes Your Immune Systems Memory Forget Defenses Against Other Illnesses. New research shows the virus can have devastating effects on the immune system that persist much longer than the illness itself. Buttigieg surges ahead of Democratic rivals in Iowa poll. South Bend Mayor Pete Buttigieg holds a clear lead among Democratic presidential candidates in Iowa, the state that will hold the first nominating contest in February, a new Des Moines Register/CNN/Mediacom opinion poll showed on Saturday. What can you do on a cold day? Is there a true free dating site Tom Hanks and Rita Wilson are a power couple at the premiere. They've been married since 1988. And Tom Hanks and Rita Wilson looked as happy as ever as they appeared at the premiere of A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood in NYC. Republicans, the Real Chickens of Kiev. A bad day for the president, from Roger Stones criminal conviction to Marie Yovanovitchs moral conviction. Facebook has been hit with a 'tsunami' of fake political news in 2019, a report finds. A report has found the Facebook was hit with a 'tsunami 'tsunami of disinformation' this year and unlike the 2016 election, this fake news is not coming from Russia - but from within the US. Prime suspect in Yvonne Fletcher murder case could finally face court, 35 years since her death. The chief suspect in the Yvonne Fletcher murder case may finally appear in court. Lawyers served civil proceedings papers this week on Saleh Ibrahim Mabrouk - the prime suspect for her murder. Invesco's equity income funds are marked down as Mark Barnett's focus on smaller firms is questioned. The manager - who is in charge of the 6.1bn Invesco High Income fund and the 2.7bn Invesco Income fund among others - worked under Neil Woodford before the latter left Invesco. Prince Andrew's regret over TV interview. The Duke of York insisted he had 'great sympathy' for anyone abused by his late paedophile friend, and had been in the dark about the 'extent of his wrongdoing'. Yodel delivery driver leaves parcel containing Bluetooth speaker in customer's TOILET. Rebeka Alam, 21, from Scunthorpe, North Lincolnshire, had ordered a new Bluetooth speaker last month and was surprised to see it had been delivered while she was at work. Dia Art Foundation Welcomes Whitney Veteran Donna De Salvo. Ms. De Salvo will advise on the collection, exhibitions and long-term installations while also developing Dias archive.